Directed by Lewis R. Foster John Payne as Clay Fletcher Gail Russell as Susan Jeffers Sterling Hayden as Bert Donner George 'Gabby' Hayes as Pesky (Pescaloosa) Tees Dick Foran as Sheriff La Farge Eduardo Noriega as Don Nacho Vázquez Henry Hull as Judge Henry Jeffers Mary Beth Hughes as Stagecoach Nellie H. B. Warner as Judge Fletcher Bobby Ellis as Jack Elkins Catherine Craig as Mrs. Elkins Arthur Space as John Elkins Steven Geray as Mexican Joe Leon Errol as Knobby Walsh Joe Kirkwood, Jr. as Joe Palooka Elyse Knox as Anne Howe Marcel Journet (actor) [fr] as Anton Kindel Sheila Ryan as Myra Madison Frank Sully as Looie Ian Wolfe as Prof. Lilliquist Walter Sande as Austin Douglass Dumbrille as Capt. Lance Douglas Fowley as Thurston Eddie Gribbon as Canvasback Ralph Graves as Dr. Colman Roland Dupree as Bellboy Gertrude Messinger as Nurse Pedro de Cordoba as Museum Caretaker